Introduction
Asbestos had once been lauded as the material of the future, thanks to its durability, fire resistance, and insulating properties. From the 1950s to the 1990s, uncountable numbers of garages, sheds, farm buildings, and industrial locations were built using asbestos. However, by the end of the last century, the harmful consequences of inhaling asbestos fibres became gradually known. These consequences ranged from fatal types of cancer to irreversible scarring of the lung tissue. For this reason, the material had been banned in 1999.
However, the buildings constructed with its help are still very much with us. It is not rare for a garage proprietor or a business owner to make an unpleasant discovery that the roof of their building(s) had been constructed with the use of asbestos. What should they do next after something like that happens?
One of the most convenient methods for dealing with an asbestos roof is called encapsulation. Encapsulation is a process where a specialized, high-performance protective coating is applied over the asbestos-containing material (ACM) to seal it, thus preventing its fibres from becoming airborne. The cost of encapsulation may vary depending on the size and the type of the building, as well as numerous other factors, which we are going to discuss below.
The Hidden Pre-Work Costs: Cleaning & Preparation
First of all, it must be checked whether the roof is covered in moss. If so, it must be cleaned first – and very carefully. It might be tempting to blast the roof clean with a jet wash, but this is actually strictly prohibited. High-pressure water is abrasive to the surface of the asbestos cement, thus releasing deadly fibres into the air. It needs to be cleaned professionally, by a licensed contractor, who will apply a “soft wash” biocide treatment and gentle manual removal.
Garages and Sheds:
How Much Will it Cost You?
| Roof Type | Encapsulation (Total) | Removal (Total) | Savings with Encapsulation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single Garage | £600–£1,500 | £950–£2,100 | 37%-29% |
| Double Garage | £1,200–£2,800 | £1,400–£3,750 | 15%-26% |
| Shed | £200–£450 | £475–£600 | 58%-25% |
What Else Do You Need to Know?
ACMs need to be legally disposed of as hazardous waste.
If you are a homeowner, you must not place asbestos in a regular bin or even take it to a standard recycling centre. Instead, you must contact the local council, who will provide details of their specific hazardous waste collection service or designated drop-off facilities.
Businesses must also provide a hazardous waste consignment note for transportation in these cases. You can find the government guidance for it here.
Commercial & Industrial Buildings:
How Much Will it Cost You?
| Project Size & Type | Encapsulation (Total) | Removal (Total) | Savings with Encapsulation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100m² warehouse roof (cement) | £3,000–£3,300 | £15,550–£20,400 | 75–81% savings |
| 200m² office refurbishment | £5,980–£6,600 | £40,000 | 82–85% savings |
| 500m² industrial facility | £14,995–£16,500 | £75,250–£161,000 | 80–90% savings |
What Else Do You Need to Know?
Under the government regulations, encapsulation falls under the definition of Notifiable Non-Licensed Work. According to CAR 2012, as a business owner, you must update the Asbestos Management Plan and pay for annual re-inspections of the encapsulated roof.
Benefits vs. Drawbacks of Asbestos Encapsulation
Encapsulation: the Pros
- Much lower cost: Encapsulation is generally more cost-effective than complete removal.
- Quicker and Less Disruption: This method minimizes interference with building operations, reducing project time considerably.
- No waste disposal required: No need for logistical difficulties and expenses of organizing dangerous waste removal.
Encapsulation: the Cons
- Not a permanent solution: Asbestos remains in place, requiring long-term monitoring and management.
- Not applicable in some cases: Encapsulation requires asbestos materials to be in good condition and not already actively unsafe or friable.
- Encapsulated asbestos is still asbestos: the known presence of asbestos, even when encapsulated, can potentially affect the property’s value and may make it difficult to sell. While mortgages on houses with asbestos are generally available, some lenders may have specific requirements, restrictions, or may require remediation before approving the mortgage offer.
Need specific advice from our engineers?
Benefits vs. Drawbacks of Complete Asbestos Removal
Removal: the Pros
- Disposes of the problem forever: Removal eliminates future health risks associated with asbestos exposure by physically taking out all ACMs.
- LRR Tax Relief: UK limited companies undertaking asbestos remediation (removal, treatment, or containment) may be eligible for Land Remediation Relief (LRR), allowing them to claim up to 150% of qualifying project costs back in corporation tax deductions.
Removal: the Cons
- Expensive: Removal costs significantly more than encapsulation does.
- Takes a long time: Removal is comparatively time-consuming and labour-intensive. This often involves significant disruption and downtime for commercial and industrial locations, resulting in potential financial losses due to halted or restricted business operations.
- Dangerous Waste Removal Required: You will need to organize the complex and costly disposal of hazardous asbestos waste by licensed carriers to a licensed disposal site.
Asbestos Encapsulation Price
| Building / Project Type | Approx. Area | Encapsulation Cost (Total) | Removal Cost (Total) | Potential Savings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garden Shed | ~10–15 m² | £200 – £450 | £475 – £600 | ~25–50% |
| Single Garage | ~20 m² | £600 – £1,500 | £950 – £2,100 | ~30–60% |
| Double Garage | ~30–40 m² | £1,200 – £2,800 | £1,400 – £3,750 | ~15–45% |
| Small Commercial Roof | 100 m² | £3,000 – £3,300 | £15,550 – £20,400 | ~80% |
| Medium Commercial / Office | 200 m² | £5,980 – £6,600 | ~£40,000 | ~85% |
| Large Industrial Facility | 500 m² | £14,995 – £16,500 | £75,250 – £161,000 | ~80–90% |
| Price Per Square Metre | Rate only | £8 – £33 per m² | £50 – £150+ per m² | — |
So, what should the verdict be? To encapsulate or not to encapsulate? Well, that depends on your specific situation – after all, there are indeed cases where removal would be more suitable (for example, if the asbestos roof had been badly preserved, or if you are sure you have the hefty budget to fund all stages of the removal). However, in most ordinary cases, encapsulation appears to be the more sensible and affordable solution that causes much less disruption to the household (or the business). Should you like our help regarding the encapsulation process, our specialists will always be glad to assist you from the first step to the last.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
How much does it cost to get a ceiling tested for asbestos?
The cost of determining if asbestos is present is usually part of a survey or sample analysis. An extensive survey of an entire property starts at £200+. General asbestos removal surveys typically cost between £200 and £1,000 depending on the size of the property. For a small 2-3 bedroom house, a survey often costs around £250.
Can I treat asbestos ceilings myself?
No, any DIY removal or treatment of asbestos is strongly discouraged. Attempting to handle asbestos without expertise or proper equipment puts you and your household at great risk. If you suspect asbestos is present, you should immediately seek specialist advice from a trained professional or an environmental health officer at your local authority.
How long does asbestos encapsulation last?
Encapsulation is considered a medium to long-term solution. High-quality systems usually offer 15-20 year warranties. The lifespan is highly dependent on factors like the type of material used, the condition of the ACMs, and environmental conditions. Closed-cell spray foam encapsulation can potentially last for an indefinite period if the underlying material is in good condition.
Is it better to remove or encapsulate asbestos?
The best option is determined by a risk assessment and the condition of the ACM. If the asbestos is in good condition and unlikely to be disturbed, encapsulation is suitable. If the asbestos is damaged, deteriorating, or if major refurbishment/demolition is planned, removal is usually necessary to eliminate the hazard and ensure long-term safety.
What sort of paint is used for asbestos encapsulation?
These products include specially formulated paints or coatings that adhere to the ACMs, such as flexible, high-build coatings, sealers, and reinforced finishes. Examples include cold-applied liquid systems, polyurethane systems, or silicone coating systems.
How safe is it to encapsulate asbestos instead of removing it?
Encapsulation, when correctly carried out by qualified and trained professionals following strict procedures, is a safe and effective method for managing ACMs. Since encapsulation involves far less disturbance than removal, it mitigates the risk of microscopic fibres becoming airborne during the process.
Conclusion
When faced with an asbestos roof, the choice between encapsulation and removal hinges on risk assessment and budget. Encapsulation, which involves applying a specialized protective coating, stands out as the more affordable and less disruptive solution for materials that are in good condition. As our cost analysis shows, this method delivers significant savings compared to the high expense and lengthy process of removal.
While encapsulation requires ongoing management, it effectively mitigates the immediate health risk. Removal remains the only permanent solution, but it is typically reserved for badly damaged ACMs or projects where complete elimination is essential.
Choosing the right path ensures both safety and regulatory compliance.
