Should Asbestos Be Removed? 5 Key Factors to Consider

Approximately 1.5 million buildings across the UK still contain asbestos, a stark reminder of a construction era that ended with the material’s complete ban in 1999. Any discovery of an asbestos roof presents a critical strategic decision: is removal necessary, or can you manage it in place?

Factor 1: Legal Obligations and Compliance Requirements

The Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 (CAR 2012) establishes the legal framework governing asbestos management in the UK. At its core lies the “Duty to Manage”—a non-delegable responsibility placed on the designated “dutyholder” to identify, assess, and continuously manage risks associated with asbestos-containing materials.

Who is the dutyholder? 

This critical question hinges on your lease structure. In Full Repairing and Insuring (FRI) leases, tenants typically assume complete responsibility for building maintenance, including asbestos management of the roof. Conversely, in multi-let premises where landlords retain control over structural elements, the landlord remains the dutyholder for common areas and the building exterior. Upon lease expiration or tenant default, dutyholder status immediately reverts to the landlord.

Dutyholders must commission accredited surveys, maintain a written asbestos register, conduct comprehensive risk assessments, develop an Asbestos Management Plan, and ensure that anyone who might disturb the building fabric receives this information before work commences.

The cost of non-compliance is severe. Prosecutions under CAR 2012 can result in fines of up to £20,000 per breach, with serious violations attracting unlimited corporate fines and up to two years imprisonment for directors. 

Factor 2: Current Condition and Risk Assessment

Not all asbestos presents equal risk. The HSE’s HSG227 risk scoring system provides a standardised methodology for determining whether management in situ is viable or removal is necessary.

The assessment combines two scores:

Material Assessment Score evaluates the intrinsic hazard based on product type, extent of damage, surface treatment, and asbestos type. Asbestos cement roofs, being highly bonded materials, typically score lower than friable materials like pipe lagging or sprayed coatings.

Priority Assessment Score evaluates the likelihood of disturbance based on normal occupant activity, accessibility, human exposure potential, and maintenance frequency. A quiet storage facility differs vastly from a high-occupancy manufacturing floor.

Refurbishment and Demolition (R&D) surveys are required before any structural work.

Factor 3: Financial Analysis

Removal costs vary significantly by property type and scale. Small commercial units may incur £1,500-£3,000 for removal, while medium office or retail sites range from £3,000-£10,000. Large industrial facilities routinely require budgets exceeding £50,000. These figures cover removal, containment, air monitoring, and disposal—excluding the replacement roof installation.

Escalating costs reflect stricter compliance requirements, skilled labour shortages, and rising landfill taxes. Hazardous waste disposal cost £126.15 per tonne in 2025, with gate fees increasing annually.

However, Land Remediation Relief (LRR) can help. UK companies subject to corporation tax can claim exceptional deductions on qualifying asbestos removal expenditure. The relief structure is generous:

  • Owner-occupiers and investors: 150% total corporation tax deduction (100% baseline plus 50% additional deduction)
  • Property developers: Standard 100% construction cost deduction plus 50% additional deduction on disposal
  • Loss-making companies: Can surrender losses for a 24% repayable cash tax credit

In other words, a £100,000 asbestos removal project generates a £150,000 tax deduction. At the 25% corporation tax rate, this produces £37,500 in tax savings—reducing the true net cost to just £62,500.

Factor 4: Property Value and Commercial Viability

Market valuation discounts of 10-20% are routine for properties with asbestos roofing. Prospective buyers conduct rigorous environmental due diligence, demanding current surveys and management plans. 

Besides, commercial lenders routinely require professional asbestos surveys before authorising finance. Severely degraded roofs or inadequate management plans result in withheld funds, costly retention clauses, or demands for full remediation as a loan condition.

Factor 5: Operational Impact: Removal vs. Encapsulation

The final strategic choice involves selecting the appropriate intervention method.

Encapsulation

Encapsulation leaves the asbestos in place, installing a new roof system directly over existing sheets. Benefits include lower upfront costs, minimal business disruption (operations can continue), and reduced acute fibre release risk during the project itself. For warehouses and factories where operational downtime equals severe revenue loss, this presents an attractive option.

Complete removal 

This method demands higher initial capital and causes operational disruption, requiring building vacation or heavy internal protection. Safety protocols are stringent, and the process is labour-intensive. On the other hand, removal also means a permanent liability elimination. The building is officially struck from the asbestos register, thus nullifying ongoing monitoring costs and future exposure risks. 

Conclusion: Making the Decision

Key takeaways:

  • Legal compliance is non-negotiable and severely penalised when breached
  • Risk assessment is dynamic—low-risk materials can rapidly escalate
  • Land Remediation Relief makes removal increasingly tax-efficient for UK businesses

Your next steps: Commission a professional asbestos survey. Our specialists can carry a survey out for you for free. 

Andy Evans

GLS Coatings

Get a free quote

Need our help with Asbestos Roof Encapsulation? Get help from our team today.
Send message

Get our help with Asbestos Roof Encapsulation today

Are you struggling with Asbestos Roof Encapsulation? Get a free quote from our helpful team today so we can help you.

What enquiry can we help you with today?

Request a Case Study

Fill in your details and we’ll send it to your inbox.

Request a Brochure

Fill in your details and we’ll send it to your inbox.