“Subsidence” is a familiar fear for many homeowners, but the ground heave – despite being its opposite – can be just as destructive. While subsidence occurs when the ground sinks, pulling foundations down, the ground heave happens when the ground expands and pushes the building upwards.
What Causes Ground Heave?
Heave is almost always the result of soil moisture increasing after a period of dryness. Depending on the area, it can also be linked to the behavior of clay soils.
Expansive Clay Ground Heave
Many parts of the UK, particularly the South East, sit on expansive clay ground heave zones. Clay minerals act like a sponge: they shrink when dry and swell when wet. When the soil beneath a house absorbs water, it expands with significant force, lifting the foundations.
Tree Removal Ground Heave
Another common trigger for serious heave is the recent removal of mature trees. A large tree can extract up to 50,000 litres of water a year, keeping the clay beneath it permanently dry and compressed. When the tree is removed, however, this water uptake naturally stops. The desiccated clay slowly rehydrates and then swells, lifting the ground.
Water Main Leak Ground Heave
This one is a little more unusual. To put it simply, a fractured pipe can dump vast quantities of water into the soil. In the cases of sandy soil, this washes away support (thus leading to subsidence), but in clay soils, it saturates the ground, causing a localized water main leak ground heave.
Seasonal Ground Heave
Clay soil naturally swells in winter (wet) and shrinks in summer (dry). This is called a seasonal ground heave. Most foundations are designed to withstand this, but if the movement exceeds the foundation’s tolerance one day, it might lead to problems.
How to Identify Ground Heave
Distinguishing ground heave vs subsidence cracks requires a careful approach, as the symptoms can appear similar.
Ground Heave vs Subsidence Cracks
- Vertical cracks: Because the ground is pushing up, masonry is often pushed apart vertically or sheared, rather than the diagonal “stepped” cracking that happens in the cases of subsidence.
- Cracks wider at the bottom: If the corners of the building are lifted, cracks may appear as an inverted ‘V’, wider at the bottom than the top.
- Closing cracks: In some cases, previous subsidence cracks may suddenly slam shut as the ground rises. Additionally, unlike seasonal subsidence cracks that close in winter, progressive heave cracks tend to remain open or worsen year-round.
Doors Sticking Ground Heave
As the foundations lift, door frames are distorted. You may find the following ground heave symptoms: the door jamming against the top of the frame or sticking at the bottom, or the frame being pushed out of square.
Floor Damage Ground Heave
Ground heave is notoriously damaging to solid concrete floors. The expanding soil pushes against the underside of the slab, causing it to dome or hump in the center. Floor damage ground heave can be identified by uneven surfaces or fresh cracks running across the middle of a room.
Ground Heave Repair and Solutions
The “Wait and See” Approach
If the heave is caused by, for example, a tree that had been removed years ago, the soil may eventually reach equilibrium all by itself. If the movement is slowing, engineers may recommend monitoring the property until it stabilizes before repairing cosmetic damage.
Ground Heave Underpinning
If a proper structural repair is needed, traditional mass concrete underpinning is rarely suitable as it provides more surface area for the clay to push against.
- Piling: Mini-piling is a preferred underpinning method for subsidence, pushing or drilling steel piles down to firmer strata. Helical piers, steel shafts installed in the damaged foundation, are also used to strengthen the structure and resist future heave.
- Anti-Heave Precautions: When underpinning occurs where clay expansion is a risk, anti-heave precautions are incorporated into the design. This involves installing compressible void formers, such as anti-heave boards like Heave Stopper or equivalent EPS products, beneath foundations and floor slabs to reduce the upward force transmitted to the structure.
Ground Heave Repair Cost
Specific numbers would vary depending on the situation; however, due to the complexity of piling and void formers, ground heave repair cost is typically higher than subsidence repair.
Ground Heave Insurance Claim
- The Excess: Most policies require the homeowner to pay a minimum excess of around £1,000 for claims related to heave. Find more information about the insurance policies on the subject here.
- Notification: You must notify your insurer as soon as you suspect damage. They will appoint experts to handle the ground heave insurance claim.
Ground Heave FAQ
1. What is the difference between ground heave and subsidence?
Subsidence is a downward movement of ground (sinking), while ground heave is an upward movement (swelling). Subsidence is often caused by soil drying out; heave, on the contrary, is caused by soil rehydrating.
2. What causes the ground heave?
The primary driver is the expansion of clay soils when they absorb water. This is most frequently triggered by the removal of mature trees (stopping water uptake), or by leaking drains saturating the ground.
3. What does heave look like in a house?
Signs include vertical cracks in brickwork, cracks that are wider at the bottom, doors sticking at the top or bottom, and concrete floors lifting or doming in the center.
4. How do I prevent ground heave after tree removal?
Do not fell mature trees near buildings on clay soil without professional advice. A sudden removal can shock the soil into rapid expansion.
5. Is heave covered by home insurance?
Yes, standard UK buildings insurance covers “subsidence, heave, and landslip” as a collective peril. However, it usually carries a standard excess of £1,000.
6. What are the common ground heave solutions?
Solutions range from monitoring (waiting for equilibrium) to ground heave underpinning using piles and “void formers” (compressible boards) that create a safety gap for the soil to expand into without lifting the house.
Ground heave can be caused by a number of causes; however, it can be fixed, too. If you would like to commission an inspection of your property to check for ground heave, contact GLS here.
