Asbestos Removal vs. Encapsulation: What to Choose for Your Property?

Finding out your property contains asbestos can bring any renovation project to a screeching halt. However, worry not: it is not an uncommon occurrence when it comes to properties built before the year 2000, and there are several tried and tested methods to deal with it. 

Of course, there is also the problem of which of those methods to choose: do you pay the premium to rip it all out (in other words, go for a complete removal) or do you choose the less invasive and more budget-friendly path of encapsulation? 

What is the Difference Between Asbestos Removal and Encapsulation?

Asbestos Encapsulation 

Asbestos encapsulation involves leaving the Asbestos Containing Material (ACM) in place, but sealing it with a specialized, high-performance coating or rigid barrier. The goal is to bind the fibers to the material, preventing them from escaping into the air.

In other words, this method treats the asbestos as a manageable risk. Rather than disturbing the hazardous fibers, a bridging or penetrating encapsulant is applied to lock them down. 

Asbestos Removal 

Asbestos removal is the complete physical elimination of the hazard from the building. 

This is also, however, a rigorous construction project involving containment, airlocks, and specialized disposal. The more detailed process is going to be described later in this post.

The Asbestos Encapsulation Process And Price

Application

The surface is first cleaned of moss and lichen – without any use of sanding or abrasive blasting, as these can release deadly fibers. 

Then, the encapsulant proper gets applied. A primer (often diluted PVA) is sprayed to penetrate the matrix of the asbestos cement, followed by a durable topcoat. 

The final result is a seamless, impact-resistant protective layer. This coating not only traps fibers but often waterproofs the roof, extending its lifespan by 10+ years at least.

Cost of Encapsulation

Encapsulation is significantly more affordable than removal, usually costing about 75% cheaper than the latter option. This is because it requires less labour and avoids high hazardous waste disposal taxes.

Project Type Est. Size Estimated Encapsulation Cost
Single Garage Roof ~18 m² ~£450
Small Residential Roof ~80 m² ~£2,000
Industrial Unit ~450 m² ~£9,000
Big Industrial Unit ~2000 m² ~£14,000
Large Industrial Unit ~10,000 m² ~£60,000

The Asbestos Removal Process And Price

Application

Removal is a labour-intensive process, and it also carries high regulatory overheads. To start with, licensed professionals must seal off the area to prevent cross-contamination. 

Then, the roof is sprayed with a surfactant (wetting agent) to minimize fiber release during movement. After that, the old sheets are removed whole. It must be noted that the fixings (hook bolts) are often corroded, which, in turn, end up requiring bolt cropping. Sheets must not be dropped, either; they are lowered to the ground mechanically or by hand.

After the painstaking removal is completed, the old asbestos sheets are double-wrapped in 1000-gauge polythene, labeled as hazardous asbestos waste, and placed in sealed skips.

After that, a modern composite panel system is installed upon the roof.

Cost of Removal

Project Type Est. Size Estimated Removal Cost
Single Garage Roof ~18 m² ~£4,500
Small Residential Roof ~80 m² ~£20,000
Industrial Unit ~450 m² ~£80,000
Big Industrial Unit ~2000 m² ~£160,000
Large Industrial Unit ~10,000 m² ~£700,000

Note: there is a critical factor that emerged in 2025: namely, the escalation of the UK Landfill Tax. To put it simply, the government utilizes this tax to divert waste from landfills, and rates for hazardous waste (which includes asbestos!) are indexed to rise significantly.

  • Landfill Tax Standard Rate (2024): £103.70 per tonne.   
  • Landfill Tax Standard Rate (April 2025): £126.15 per tonne.   
  • Gate Fees: In addition to the tax, landfill operators charge a “gate fee.” Due to the scarcity of sites licensed to accept hazardous waste, these fees are rising.
  • Total Disposal Cost: The combined cost (Tax + Gate Fee + Transport) for asbestos disposal alone as of 2025 is estimated to be between £200 and £500 per tonne. 

Pros and Cons of asbestos encapsulation

Pros:

  • Cost-Effective: Costs a mere fraction of what the removal would.
  • Speed: The process is comparatively fast.
  • Minimal Disruption: Residents or workers can usually remain in the building.
  • Preservation: Ideal for listed buildings where removing original materials would have required a complex planning permission.

Cons:

  • Maintenance: The hazard technically remains; you would have to inspect the coating regularly to ensure it hasn’t degraded.
  • Condition Dependent: You cannot encapsulate friable (that is, crumbling) or severely damaged asbestos.

Pros and Cons of asbestos removal

Pros:

  • Peace of Mind: The primary benefit is the total elimination of the risk. You no longer have to worry about the asbestos register.
  • Value: Increases property marketability, as buyers often fear buying homes with “managed” asbestos.

Cons:

  • Disruption: The affected area becomes an off-limits zone during the works.
  • Complex: Requires notification to the HSE (ASB5 form) and arranging for the licensed waste transport.
  • Risk of Release: The act of breaking out asbestos carries a temporary spike in risk if not managed perfectly.

DIY vs. Professional: Can You Deal with Asbestos  Yourself?

The real question is, “should you deal with asbestos yourself” – and the answer is usually a resounding “no”. 

Engaging in any work that disturbs asbestos carries significant risks and requires effective controls, appropriate training, and specialized equipment (such as P3 standard masks, disposable overalls, and specific procedures for disposal). Improper disposal of asbestos waste is a criminal offense. Given the legal and safety complexities, it is always safer and easier to hire trained professionals.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can asbestos be safely encapsulated?

Yes, provided the asbestos is in good condition and not “friable” (easily crumbled). The HSE accepts encapsulation as a valid management technique.

2. Is it better to remove or encapsulate asbestos?

That depends. Encapsulation is preferred for the more “everyday” maintenance: after all, it minimizes the cost and the risk of disruption. Removal is the more drastic way that might be better if you are, for example, planning major renovation works in the building. 

3. How to maintain encapsulated asbestos roofs?

You must schedule annual visual inspections to check for any signs of peeling. You also have to ensure no one walks on the asbestos roof so as not to run the risk of damaging the coating. 

4. How long does encapsulation last?

A high-quality encapsulation system typically lasts 10 to 25 years.

5. When is asbestos removal necessary?

Removal is mandatory if the material is significantly damaged, or if the building is being demolished.

6. Can a homeowner remove asbestos themselves?


Better not – even if you disregard the danger to your own household (which you really shouldn’t be doing!), keep in mind that you can be prosecuted if you cause fiber release that affects neighbours. Hiring a professional is always the safest route.

Conclusion

In summary, both methods of dealing with asbestos have their place – however, unless you are looking for a drastic solution and can afford the hefty investment that removal requires, encapsulation might be your best bet. If you want to make the first steps in ensuring that your home (or place of business) remains safe from asbestos fibres for decades to come, contact GLS Coatings here. 

Andy Evans

GLS Coatings

Get a free quote

Need our help with Asbestos Roof Encapsulation? Get help from our team today.
Send message

Get our help with Asbestos Roof Encapsulation today

Are you struggling with Asbestos Roof Encapsulation? Get a free quote from our helpful team today so we can help you.

What enquiry can we help you with today?

Request a Case Study

Fill in your details and we’ll send it to your inbox.

Request a Brochure

Fill in your details and we’ll send it to your inbox.